Patrick Mahomes or Jayden Daniels? Debating the most valuable player in the NFL

Date:

The Washington Commanders have found their franchise quarterback in Jayden Daniels, and a growing number of fans believe he is already the most valuable asset in the NFL.

His electrifying rookie campaign has sparked debates across social media, with a majority of Commanders supporters claiming there isn’t a single player they would trade him for.

A recent Reddit thread discussing this topic saw passionate arguments from Washington fans on both sides, with many fans convinced of Daniels’ value while others urged caution.

Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels

Jan 18, 2025; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels (5) scrambles out of the pocket during the fourth quarter against Detroit Lions in a 2025 NFC divisional round game at Ford Field. Mandatory Credit: Lon Horwedel-Imagn Images / Lon Horwedel-Imagn Images

READ MORE: Super Bowl in D.C.? Mayor says it’s possible with a new Commanders stadium

“I can’t think of a player I would accept 1:1 for JD,” one fan argued. “If he replicates his rookie season success in his second year, I think it becomes indisputable that he’s the most valuable asset in the league.”

Others fans point to the financial aspect, noting the cost-effectiveness of having an elite young quarterback on a rookie contract.

“I can’t imagine the gap between him and say Mahomes, or Allen, or Jackson, is worth the $40-50M difference in cap hit,” another fan pointed out.

However, not everyone is ready to crown Daniels just yet. Some Commanders fans urge caution, reminding others of how quickly narratives can change.

“I love you guys and love Jayden Daniels, but gotta pump the brakes a little,” one skeptical fan said. “The recency bias takes on Mahomes are wild lol. Obviously, his contract factors in, but Mahomes is a more valuable asset right now.”

Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes reacts in the fourth quarter against the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LIX.

Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes reacts in the fourth quarter against the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LIX at Ceasars Superdome. / Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

Others suggest waiting for a second year of production before making such a claim.

“Last year they would have said that about Stroud, but probably not after his second year,” another commenter noted.

While opinions remain divided, one thing is clear: Washington has a young star in Daniels, and his future could define the franchise for years to come. Whether he is truly the most valuable asset in the NFL, only time will tell.

READ MORE: Analysts urge Commanders to sign wide receiver Tee Higgins

Stick with CommanderGameday and the Locked On Commanders podcast for more FREE coverage of the Washington Commanders throughout the 2024 season.

• Commanders named a top landing spot for Super Bowl champion WR

• NFL executive slams Commanders, praises Jayden Daniels

• 3 top defensive NFL Draft prospects that would fill Commanders’ needs

• Commanders hold top odds to land former NFL Defensive Player of the Year

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

San Francisco 49ers’ Talanoa Hufanga Best NFL Free Agency Fits: Houston Texans?

After going from a fifth-round selection in the 2021...

Cardinals Hint at NFL Draft Plans

The Arizona Cardinals enter the 2025 NFL Draft with...

Chappell Roan's Makeup Stole the Show at Paris Fashion Week

Chappell Roan's sense of style has already been solidified...