According to Jamie Carragher’s recent analysis in The Telegraph, Tottenham’s appointment of Ange Postecoglou brought with it a wave of excitement about a potential return to a more visually appealing style of football. The optimism was fuelled by the chairman Daniel Levy’s declaration at a supporters’ meeting, saying, “We have our Tottenham back.” However, the practical results so far suggest a mixed bag—entertaining football, yet lacking the consistency needed to challenge for top honours with Carragher also labelling them as “too easy to play against”.
Postecoglou’s Spurs have proven to be a treat for neutral fans, with a style that guarantees goals at both ends. “Whenever Spurs visit the toughest venues… you anticipate an entertaining game and a home win,” Carragher observes. This brand of football, while exhilarating, underscores a deeper issue: the team’s inability to perform against top-tier clubs, which has relegated them to what some might call “flat-track bullies.”
Defensive Vulnerabilities and Tactical Questions
Under Postecoglou, Tottenham have shown vulnerabilities, especially from set pieces and in maintaining defensive solidity. The team’s central defensive pairing of Cristian Romero and Mickey van de Ven, while individually talented, seem to be too exposed within the current tactical setup. Carragher notes, “It is a valid tactical discussion as to whether they are being left too exposed and might benefit from a more balanced set-up.”
The manager’s often quoted mentorship under Ferenc Puskas, where the ethos was to win games with a high score line, resonated well initially. However, the charm of such an approach has waned as the team struggles to keep clean sheets, achieving just three in their last 26 Premier League outings.
Navigating Transitions and Transfer Strategies
Tottenham’s recent transfer strategy has involved significant investments in young talents rather than established stars, marking a clear shift in approach. “Around £379 million has been spent,” Carragher points out, highlighting the club’s focus on potential future gains rather than immediate impact players. This strategy places a significant bet on Postecoglou’s ability to develop these young talents into top-tier performers—a gamble that has yet to pay off convincingly.
Perception Versus Reality in Spurs’ Ambitions
The real crux of Tottenham’s current scenario lies in the expectations set by historical achievements versus the reality of their present ambitions. As Carragher eloquently puts it, different clubs have different interpretations of what it means to be ‘back.’ For Spurs, the memories of the Pochettino era and even further back to the 1980s under Keith Burkinshaw, where they achieved notable successes, seem to be the benchmark.
Yet, the ongoing season and the last raise questions about whether such benchmarks are still realistic or if they set the club up for perceived underachievement. The challenging aspect in assessing Spurs in this period is understanding the true summit of their ambitions—are they aiming to consistently challenge for titles, or is a top-four finish the more immediate goal?
Our View – EPL Index Analysis
It’s hard not to feel a mixture of hope and frustration. Postecoglou’s appointment promised a shift towards more entertaining football, and on that front, he has delivered. However, the lack of consistency, particularly against top teams, is disheartening.
Seeing Arsenal solidify their approach and start to reap rewards only adds to the sting. We’ve spent a substantial amount on promising talents like Dominic Solanke and Brennan Johnson, but the transition from good to great seems slow. While the investment in youth might pay off in the future, the current results and the seeming lack of tactical balance raise concerns.
What’s more, the feeling that every setback might erode the goodwill towards Postecoglou is unsettling. As fans, we understand the need for patience in a transitional period, but there also needs to be tangible progress. If the Spurs management believes that entertaining football is enough to satisfy supporters without the accompanying success, they might need to reassess their strategy. As the next transfer window approaches, decisive action will be needed to ensure that our ambitions align with our potential.
